Henry
VIII and some of those who incurred his wrath - Nicholas Carew, Henry Courtenay,
Thomas Dingley, Thomas Fines, John Fisher, Thomas Fitzgerald, John Forest, Adrian
Fortescue, John Frith, John Lambert, Thomas More, Edward Neville, John Neville,
Geoffrey Pole, Henry Pole, Margaret Pole, Reginald Pole, and Thomas Wolsey.
Also Henry's 17th century biographer, Edward Herbert.
The reign of Henry VIII (1509-47) was not a good time to
be in the limelight. The famous figures of the day more often died in bloody
circumstances than in their beds, and the number of people persecuted, one way
or another, is too great to list. The work shown here is Lord Herbert of Cherbury's
history, which on the whole presents Henry in a positive light and consequently
does not go into full details of all of those who incurred Henry's wrath.
The account below omits or mentions only in passing those
whose imprisonment and/or execution is mentioned by Herbert, but whose sufferings
cannot be attributed - at least in part - to their religious beliefs. Among
these are Anne Boleyn, George Boleyn, William Brereton, Thomas Cromwell, Thomas
Culpeper, Francis Derham, Mary Douglas, Thomas Fines, Leonard Gray, Catherine
Howard, Henry Howard, Thomas Howard, Walter Hungerford, Henry Norris, Mark Smeton
and Francis Weston.
I start with Cardinal Wolsey (1475-1530), although he fell
foul of Henry, not by differing from him in religious matters, but by failing
to procure an annulment of Henry's marriage to Catherine of Aragon, thus proving
an impediment to Anne Boleyn's ambitions to become queen. She, rather than the
king, was his nemesis, together with 17 nobles, who denounced him in 14 articles
submitted to the king in 1529. He fell ill and died, shortly after being arrested
for high treason, on November 28th, 1530.
Theoretically, though, the severance from Rome was not complete
until 1535, so Wolsey's death preceded the Reformation, as did the burning of
the Protestant John Frith (1503-33) on July 4th, 1533 (Herbert gives the date
as July 20th, 1534).
Following the definitive break with Rome, Herbert passes
over the brutal executions of Prior Houghton, Dr. Reynolds, and John Hale, Vicar
of Isleworth (see DNB), moving straight on to Sir Thomas More (1478-1535)
and John Fisher (1459-1535), Bishop of Rochester, beheaded, as Herbert says,
"for denying the Kings Supremacy". In fact, their offence was refusing to accept
the Act of Succession, which went quite a bit further than simply naming Henry
and Anne's children as successors to the throne. Herbert also mentions, without
naming, eleven monks, who were also executed at this time.
Next to lose their heads in Herbert's account are Anne Boleyn
and those accused of being her paramours (including her brother, George) The
accusations are generally believed to be false, but Herbert gives credence to
them.
Herbert notes the execution (in February, 1537) of Thomas
Fitzgerald, Earl of Kildare and his five uncles, who had been kept in Tyburn
following the 1536 Lincolnshire rebellion. Their deaths may have been partly
a consequence of their religious beliefs, since the rebellion had been sparked
partly by high taxes and partly by resistance to religious change and the dissolution
of the monasteries.
Next in Herbert's account are two religious martyrdoms.
The friar John Forest (1474?-1538), was burned along with a sacred image for
refusing to accept the king's supremacy and encouraging others to do likewise,
and John Lambert (vere Nicholson) was burned in 1538 for denying the real presence
of Christ in the Eucharist. He then gives an account of those arraigned for
maintaining treasonable connections with Cardinal Reginald Pole, who had left
the country. Edward Neville, Henry Courtenay, Marquis of Exeter and Henry Pole,
Baron Montague (Reginald's brother), were beheaded in 1538, Nicholas Carew,
Adrian Fortescue and Thomas Dingley in 1539, and Reginald Pole's mother, Margaret
Pole, the Countess of Salisbury, was executed barbarously in 1541. Reginald's
other brother, Geffrey, and Courtenay's wife, Gertrude, originally condemned
with the others, were later released.
After the execution of Thomas Cromwell, in 1540, Herbert notes, with no apparent
irony, "And now a cruell time did passe in England" (p. 466), and there
follows an account of a spate of beheadings which took place over the next couple
of years, followed by lean times for the executioner until the beheading of
Henry Howard, the Earl of Surrey, on charges of treason, just before Henry's
death.
Herbert's history is the standard 17th century account of
Henry's life. The author, Lord Edward Herbert of Cherbury (1583-1648), was one
of the leading figures of in the first half of the 17th century,
associating with such figures as John Donne and Ben Jonson.
The
Life and Raigne of King Henry the Eighth. Written By the Right Honourable Edward
Lord Herbert of Cherbury. (London,
Printed by E.G. for Thomas Whitaker, and are to be sold at his shop, at the
Kings Arms in Pauls Church-yard. 1649, fol., pp. 10+575+7.) A very good copy
of a seminal text, complete in a well-preserved contemporary binding. The frontispiece
engraving of Henry, pictured above, is often missing. Pages 513-520 are misbound
between pages 504-505.